| Platinum | La Grotta |
| Platinum | Mona Lisa Ristorante Italiano |
| Gold | The Old Spaghetti Factory |
| Silver | Santa Lucia Pizza |
| Bronze | Little Nana's |
| Top Pick | Block & Blade Restaurant and Bar |
| Top Pick | Harth Mozza and Wine Bar |
| Top Pick | Kevin's |
| Top Pick |
Monticchio Ristorante Italiano
|
| Top Pick | Pasquale's Italian Ristorante |
