| Platinum |
Frank's Pizza
|
| Gold | Santa Lucia Pizza |
| Silver |
Sorrento’s Bar & Pizzeria
|
| Bronze |
A Little Pizza Heaven
|
| Top Pick | Dal's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick |
Fast Fired by Carbone
|
| Top Pick |
Gondola Pizza
|
| Top Pick | Red Ember Common |
| Top Pick | Wall Street Slice |
