| Platinum | Sargent Sundae |
| Gold | Chaeban Ice Cream |
| Silver | Dug & Betty's Ice Creamery |
| Bronze | Sub Zero Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Banana Boat |
| Top Pick | Bridge Drive-In |
| Top Pick | Dairy Delight |
| Top Pick | Fête Ice Cream & Coffee |
| Top Pick | Sweet Annie’s Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Sweet Tops Ice Cream |