| Platinum | Papa's Bake House |
| Gold | Mountain Bean |
| Silver | French Way Café |
| Bronze | De Luca's |
| Top Pick | Cleocatra Cafe |
| Top Pick | Colosimo Coffee Roasters |
| Top Pick | Grace Cafe |
| Top Pick | GrandDonut Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Modern Coffee |
| Top Pick | San Vito Coffee House |