| Platinum | Taverna Rodos Restaurant & Lounge |
| Gold | Olympia Diner |
| Silver | Super Boy's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Helios Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Garwood Grill |
| Top Pick | Homer's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jimmy The Greek |
| Top Pick | Kristina's on Corydon |
| Top Pick | Red Top Drive Inn |
| Top Pick | Santa Lucia Pizza |